Summary
It is no secret that thePercy Jacksonmovie adaptations got a lot wrong about the source material. Everyone, including Rick Riordan himself, has criticized the movies for their complete failure to understand the books and their most vital components.ThePercy Jacksonmovie franchise only made it through two movies before buckling under the weight of its mistakes;the second movie awkwardly tries to correct some of the things from the first, to little avail.
These two movies changed so many things about thePercy Jacksonstory that none of the original tone or messages came through,and many of the characters were unrecognizable. The filmmakers cut some fan-favorite scenes and character traits that many were doubtlessly looking forward to seeing when they heard about the adaptation. After this failed movie franchise,Percy Jacksonremained untouched for 10 years before being rebooted as the far more successful Disney+ TV show, withPercy Jackson and the Olympiansseason 2now on the horizon.
Release date
Metacritic score
Audience score
2010
49%
47%
53%
2013
42%
39%
54%
Percy Jackson Season 2 Filming Start Seemingly Announced By Director In BTS Photo
Director James Bobin seemingly confirms Percy Jackson season 2 is officially filming as he shares a behind-the-scenes photo of an iconic location.
8The Percy Jackson Movies Changed The Characters' Ages
Percy is 12 years old in the first book, while he is 16 in the first movie.
The most obvious change that put off viewers (at least the ones that read the books) right away was how Percy and his peers were all aged up several years from how old they are at the beginning of the story in the source material.Percy is 12 years old inThe Lightning Thief, which is important to the story because it all leads up to the Great Prophecy,which states that he will either save or destroy Olympus when he turns 16. The second movie tries to fix this by centering the prophecy around his 18th birthday.
Additionally, changing the characters' ages dramatically altered the movie’s tone, hurting its ability to get through to the people for whom the story was written.ThePercy Jacksonbooks are a careful blend of lighthearted comedy and true danger,written for an audience around the same age as Percy, so they can see themselves in him and his friends. When Percy was reintroduced as a 16-year-old, much of the existing fanbase would have felt like the story was no longer for them.
Making the child characters older has worked in some adaptations, such as withThe Chronicles of Narnia, which is illustrative of what thePercy Jacksonfilmmakers were probably hoping for. However,Narniastill had Lucy to ground the story with themes of childhood, whilePercy Jacksonbecame a movie only about teenagers.The right move would have been to accept that 12-year-olds accomplishing all that they do is a little unrealistic, but they are demigods, and them being this age is too important to the story and the fans.
7The Percy Jackson Movies Changed The Nature Of Percy’s First Quest
Percy is not granted an official quest in the Lightning Thief movie.
InThe Lightning Thief, Percy is officially chosen by the camp counselors/the gods to go on the quest to find theMaster Lightning Bolt and return it to Zeus, as Percy is the primary suspect of its theft and needs to prove his innocence to prevent a war. Percy is partially motivated to accept by wanting to go to the Underworld to rescue his mother. However,the movie shows Percy receiving no quest, and leaving camp against orders to rescue Sally,with Annabeth and Grover in tow. Therefore, not only does the movie make the characters older, but the adults expect less of the demigods.
It is a lazy plot device to get Percy and the others moving when their plan should have ended in disaster.
The setting might be a lot kinder to these teenagers, but that’s not really the point of the story. Clarisse is given a quest in the second movie, but this doesn’t fix the plot holes created bychanging the quest inThe Lightning Thief.Percy — and Annabeth and Grover for supporting him — comes across as dangerously naivefor basing his whole plan around simply explaining to Hades that he didn’t steal the Master Bolt. It is a lazy plot device to get Percy and the others moving when their plan should have ended in disaster.
6The Percy Jackson Movies Messed Up Annabeth’s Characterization
Few of Annabeth’s core traits appear in the Percy Jackson movies.
When theLightning Thiefmovie first came out, there were a lot of complaints about Annabeth not being blonde, leading to Alexandra Daddario dyeing her hair forSea of Monsters.Leah Sava Jeffries faced a racist casting backlashwhen she was chosen as Annabeth for the TV show, showcasing a widespread disregard of what is really important about the character. Indeed,there is a lot more wrong with Annabeth’s characterization than her hair color in the movies,while Jeffries' performance is much more faithful to Annabeth’s confident and intellectual personality.
The movies grant Annabeth opportunities to demonstrate her skills as a warrior, but not as a strategist or scholar.Annabeth is a huge architecture nerd and corrects all the problems in the plansPercy comes up with. However, Daddario’s Annabeth is a pretty generic action heroine. She beats Percy up in training (her strategic move of giving Percy up to the opposing team is cut) before she illogically jumps at the chance to join his"quest.“On the other hand, the TV show begins to lay the groundwork for this aspect of Annabeth’s character in season 1.
5The Percy Jackson Movies Cut The Gateway Arch Sequence
One of the best parts of the quest for the Master Bolt isn’t included in the movie.
Percy’s quest is restructured in more ways than one in the first movie. The sequences of him, Annabeth, and Grover fighting Medusa and getting stuck in the Lotus Casino were kept, butthe confrontation with Echidna and the Chimera at the St. Louis Arch was replaced by the Hydra at the Parthenon replica in Nashville.In doing this, the plot loses some amusing beats that contribute to the book’s overall tone — such as leaning into the slightly ludicrous nature of the story when Percy realizes his best option is to jump from the arch.
This also segues into Percy realizing that he will be healed by fresh water and that he can breathe underwater. In the movie, Percy realizes the former during training at camp, while some of Percy’s other more specific powers are cut. In contrast,Percy’s battle with the Hydra is too similar to many other fantasy action sequences,with a lot of fire and destruction before the heroes inevitably triumph. It demonstrates how the movies made many small changes that ultimately amounted toPercy Jacksonlosing what made the story unique.
10 Books To Read If You Love Percy Jackson
Rick Riordan’s Percy Jackson books take a unique approach to mythology and have a fun and distinct voice – so what should readers pick up after?
4The Percy Jackson Movies Didn’t Give Luke Strong Motives
A new plot detail in the Lightning Thief movie completely undermines Luke’s character.
The gods are supposed to be complicated, not completely moral characters inPercy Jackson. There is ample material for this when there is a long history of the gods abusing mortals in Greek mythology, and it is what gives rise to Luke leading a rebellion of demigods with the intent of destroying Olympus.Luke’s hatred for the gods is specifically rooted in how they treat their children:Many of them are absent and never claim their half-mortal offspring, or send them on dangerous missions only for the sake of glory.
However, theLightning Thiefmovie says that the gods are forbidden from contacting their demigod children. This completely undermines Luke’s villainous plot, cheapening his hatred of his father. The movies wanted to have it both ways, with Poseidon and Athena being affectionate parents thatPercy and Annabethwould want to fight for, while still having Luke serve as the story’s antagonist.The hard truth is that they needed to dedicate more time to figuring out the nuances of the part ofPercy Jackson,but they rushed the writing and production of what they thought would be a profitable movie.
3The Percy Jackson Movies Cut Everything Cool From Sea Of Monsters
Blackjack, Circe, and Blackbeard do not appear in the Sea of Monsters movie.
The Lightning Thiefcut one exciting aspect of the quest for the Master Bolt, butSea of Monsterscut everything fun about the quest for the Golden Fleece.In the book, Percy and Annabeth have a run-in with Circe along the way,which leads to an interesting conversation between Annabeth and Circe about female demigods' deeds being forgotten and the discovery that Circe had imprisoned the pirate Blackbeard (who is a son of Ares) and his crew for centuries. In a different sequence, Percy frees a pegasus named Blackjack from Luke’s ship, who becomes Percy’s hilarious and loyal steed.
Circe, Blackbeard, and Blackjack didn’t make it into theSea of Monstersmovie.The movie includes a lot of flashy visuals, like the hippocampi and Kronos himself in the final act, but none of the extremely goofy elements, like a historical pirate leading a reckless charge or a wise-cracking pegasus. The filmmakers faced tough choices about what to cut for time but chose poorly as they removed more beloved parts of the series, making the second movie even more disappointing than the first.
2The Percy Jackson Movies' Depiction Of The Gods Is Wrong
The gods don’t have individual personalities in the Percy Jackson movies.
A huge component ofPercy Jackson’ssetting is that the gods have adopted modern personas and appearancessuited to the 21st century. The gods and monsters alike incorporate things like office complexes and game shows into their gimmicks; the Olympians usually appear wearing modern garments associated with whatever they are the gods of. For instance, Poseidon typically dresses like a fisherman or a surfer, wearing Hawaiian shirts and Bermuda shorts. The gods as seen in the TV show have specialized wardrobes.
However, in the movies, only Hades and Hermes are given any individuality, and not as much as in the books or show.Most of the gods are only seen wearing Ancient Greek attire.Additionally, their personalities are static; they are all vaguely domineering and powerful and don’t have very complicated relationships with their children. One of the things that makesPercy Jacksonsuch a textured, entertaining series is the depiction of how the gods' different temperaments play into their relationships with each other and their demigod children, which may have massive consequences for the world.
All 11 Greek Gods In Disney’s Percy Jackson TV Show Explained
Disney’s Percy Jackson and the Olympians TV show, which covers Rick Riordan’s The Lightning Thief and its sequels, features multiple Greek gods.
1The Percy Jackson Movies Failed To Capture The Books' Tone
The movies fail to capture the dangerous yet wacky story of Percy Jackson.
Yet the biggest overall problem, which is evident through some other mistakes, is thatthePercy Jacksonmovies take themselves too seriously.As a result, the fandom doesn’t think of them as worthwhile at all. There is an evident desire on the part of the filmmakers to cut out things that were too crazy and makePercy Jacksonan epic tale about a noble young hero’s coming of age. This is what the books are — to an extent. However, what Riordan did in the process was create a unique setting that would have the biggest impact on children.
Cutting elements like hilarious pegasi and the gods wearing beach attire hurt the Percy Jackson movies.
Cutting elements like hilarious pegasi and the gods wearing beach attire hurt thePercy Jacksonmovies. They became just another generic fantasy adventure struggling to replaceHarry Potter. The movies convey none of the world’s humorous tone (a few funny comments are not enough), which is supposed to balance out the danger of fighting mythological monsters. They made what they thought would be more marketable movies, which only resulted in greater losses and the franchise eventually being rebooted.
