Where is James Reyes now? Sherri Papini slams ex in new documentary
Sherri Papiniis breaking her silence nearly a decade after faking her own kidnapping in the newdocu-seriesCaught in the Lie. Now, she’s claiming her captor was her ex-boyfriend, James Reyes.
On July 02, 2025, Papini went missing while on a jog near her home in Redding, California. Her husband, Keith Papini, and their two children were left fearing the worst, sparking a nationwide hunt. Then, 22 days later, she returned. She was chained, emaciated, covered in bruises, burn marks, and had even been branded.
For years, she claimed her kidnappers were two Hispanic women (whoshe nicknamed Smegmaand Taint in her own writeup of the incident). The FBI noticed holes in her story, but it wasn’t until March 2022 that she was finally arrested. Law enforcement proved that she had been staying at her ex boyfriend’s house, convincing him to help her harm herself.
She signed a plea deal admitting to the hoax, and was sentenced to 18 months in prison and ordered to pay $300,000. However, her story has changed in ID’s newtrue crimedocumentary series, where she claims Reyes was the aggressor.
Where is James Reyes now?
The producers of Sherri Papini: Caught in the Lie hired a private investigator to catch up with Reyes, where it’s revealed that he’s currentlyliving a quiet life in Nogales, Arizona, where he looks after his 95-year-old grandfather.
The private investigator was also able to discover that Reyes’ mother is Irish, which contradicts Papini’s earlier claims in thenew documentary. According to her latest account, she chose to lie about two women kidnapping her as she thought Reyes’ mother was Hispanic.
Where is “You” stalker Christopher Thomas? Update on Stalking Samantha: 13 Years of Terror
Prosecutors want death penalty for YouTuber charged with killing rival & wife on stream
Amy Bradley is Missing creators change mind on what happened after “compelling” evidence
She alleges she didn’t want to outright tell police that Reyes had kidnapped her, so she thought that by describing the likeness of his mother would give them a clue and somehow lead them to him.
Reyes was interrogated by law enforcement after they discovered his DNA on Papini and found out that she had been at his home. He explained that she had lied to him, falsely claiming her husband, Keith, had been abusing her.
He also stated that Papini had inflicted the injuries on herself or had convinced him to help her. In August 2020, three days before Sherri’s final interview with law enforcement, he took a polygraph test and passed every question.
Following his interviews, he was cleared of any wrongdoing. Peter French, a retired FBI special agent involved in the case, says, “I actually spoke to the individual who conducted that test.
“The individual who conducted that test went to the same school that I went to, which is a very rigorous course to become a polygraph examiner. And that examiner said he passed.
“That guy gave a story, a statement that we were able to corroborate and he was much more credible than someone who gave several stories and even now still can’t be corroborated.
“When you tell the truth, there are corroborations that bind that story together. When you’re making stuff up, it’s impossible sometimes to prove or disprove. It just is. And it’s hard to corroborate Sherri Papini’s claims.
“She had four years when she could’ve said, ‘You know what, I was having marital problems at the time so that’s why I had these events take place.’ She never said that.”
Sherri Papini: Caught in the Lie Episodes 1-2 arestreamingon Max now, while Episodes 3-4 air on Tuesday, May 27 from 9-11pm ET/PT on ID and Max.
For more true crime news, read aboutwhy Fred West needed an appropriate adult, theMenendez brothers’ new sentencing, andwhere Molly Martens is now.
